We think love is a feeling. But the Bible never commanded an emotion. It commanded a contract.
- Nicholas Townsend Smith M.S. (I/O Psychology)

- 2 hours ago
- 4 min read

We think love is a feeling. But the Bible never commanded an emotion. It commanded a contract.
The coffee is black today. No cream. Just the bitter, clean bite of the roast hitting the back of my throat while the morning light catches the dust motes floating static in the air.
I am sitting here looking at the text. I realize we have been reading it backward.
We interpret ancient commands through modern moods.
We wait for the "feeling" of love to wash over us before we act. We wait for the affection (Philia) to validate the obedience. But that is the Germanic definition of love. Not the Greek one.
The Greek authors weren't asking for your heart to flutter. They were asking for your allegiance.
The Architecture of Allegiance
Agape is a decision of the will, completely detached from the fluctuation of sentiment.
In the ancient Near East, "love" was a political term describing the loyalty between a vassal and a king, not the affection between friends. It was about fulfilling the terms of a treaty. Regardless of how you felt about the monarch.
The confusion is linguistic drift.
We speak a Germanic tongue. Our word "Love" comes from the Old English lufu, which is deeply rooted in affection, desire, and fondness. It’s warm. It’s fuzzy. It’s involuntary.
The Greek authors of the New Testament were operating on a completely different frequency.
The Romans 9 Paradox
Biblical election is a functional choice regarding lineage and role, not an emotional assessment of personal worth or affection.
Romans 9. This is the chapter that breaks people. "Jacob I have loved, but Esau I have hated."
If you read that with English ears, God sounds like a monster. He sounds petty. Emotionally volatile.
But look at the Greek function:
Love (Agapaō): To choose for a specific purpose or covenant.
Hate (Miseō): To reject for that specific purpose.
God wasn't saying, "I have warm fuzzies for Jacob and malicious anger toward Esau." He was saying, "I have chosen Jacob for the line of the Messiah, and I have passed over Esau for that role."
It’s not malice. It’s selection.
The Freedom of "Not Liking"
True spiritual maturity is found in the gap between emotional repulsion and obedient action.
This distinction is the only thing that makes the command to "Love your neighbor" possible.
If God is commanding me to feel affection for the guy who betrayed me, He is setting me up for failure. I can't manufacture Philia (friendship/affection). That is biologically impossible in the moment of trauma.
But I can manufacture Agape.
I can choose to act in his best interest. I can choose not to retaliate. I can choose to seek his good. Even while my stomach turns.
Love is the policy. Affection is just the weather.
The Trap of "Germanic" Faith
We get stuck because we judge our spiritual maturity by our emotional temperature.
"I didn't feel it during worship." "I don't feel loving toward my spouse right now."
So what?
The Greek text suggests that your feelings are irrelevant to your obedience.
Think about the "Giants and the Smalls" framework here. A "Small" waits to feel good before acting. A "Giant" acts because they are committed to the outcome. Regardless of the internal resistance.
"Where am I demonstrating love in the Greek sense by my commitment to something?"
That is the question.
If you get up and serve your family when you are exhausted and annoyed, you are loving them perfectly in the Agape sense. You are valuing their needs above your comfort. The fact that you don't feel like doing it actually makes the love more pure. It proves it's not just a dopamine chase.
It’s a sacrifice.
The Reframe
Stop checking your emotional pulse.
Check your hands. Are they doing the work? Check your will. Is it aligned?
We have to stop trying to force an ancient Eastern library into a modern Western emotional framework. It doesn't fit.
I am realizing that my commitment is the highest form of intimacy. Even when it feels cold.
Where are you waiting for the "feeling" to arrive before you sign the contract?
Here Are 4 Ways We Can Walk Together If you are ready to reclaim your agency, here is how you can move forward:
The Archive: Visit the website. I have dumped hundreds of videos, blog posts, and "brain candy" there. It is all free. Take what you need to build your own map. The Test: Curious if the 12 Journeys are for you? Drop a comment with the word 'WISDOM' and I’ll send you the first week’s framework for free. Test the methodology yourself. No strings attached. The Cohort: Ready to stop drifting? Register for our SG Programs and do the work alongside a community of Giants. The Proximity: If you need to go deeper, ask me about working 1-on-1.
Legal Disclaimer: Services provided are for educational and wellness coaching purposes only in compliance with Utah SB48 & SB26. We do not diagnose or treat clinical mental health conditions. This is not a substitute for professional therapy. In a crisis? Call or text 988.



Comments